I listened to every version of Sugaree from 1974 and 1985 💪🤯👍 What I heard changed me... FOREVER! 😱
Click - baited 🪝Lol
It's true, I did listen to all of those versions and found something that I think is pretty cool.
Sugaree first came out in '71, Which coincides with Micky leaving the band from about '71 to '74. I chose to listen to '74 because at that point the song, with Billy as the only drummer, had worked into it's most refined shape given that incarnation of the Grateful Dead. In those shows you can really hear Billy's swinging backbeat, and Jerry’s phrasing is clearly responding to that feel. Jerry's timing and phrasing is very much a 4/4 bouncing between the two chord movement.
✨HOWEVER✨… by the mid 80s, obv Mickey is back, and the whole feel of the song is different. The drumming and the band/song’s phrasing starts to feel like it’s counting in 8 rather than 4. We have a strong pulse, “And Uh ONE”, then the count cycles to 8. Sure it's possible to count in 4/4, or even 2/4 but, the strongest downbeat is that "ba-ds-daa-DUMP" on the B, and to my ear this feels like 8/4 time.
This shift actively de-emphasizes the move from the B chord to the E, or the 5 to the 1. The chord change now falls on beat 5. The effect of this is that the tonal center doesn’t land on the key center of E, our ear rests on the tonal center of B.
⚡️In this light, Jerry’s phrasing naturally shifts into longer, eight count ideas.⚡️
As I began thinking and listening in this way, one of the things I started to hear is that Jerry is almost always working in sets of 4 of those 8 count phrases. He don’t follow a strict pattern (no surprise there 🤪) but he does almost always use the first three phrases establish an idea, such as an A B A C, and that fourth phrase breaks out and pushes forward.
This idea of thinking in sets of phrases and then altering the fourth, has been a big shift mentally for me. 🎸🧠
What you’re seeing in the first half of the video is m playing a routine that I’ve worked out. There’s a part at the very beginning on the low E string that I stole from Jerry from a 1985 Atlanta show, along with the other part up by the 12th fret. I don't think he'll mind.
Working those out has been a lot of fun, especially seeing how Jerry moves in and around these shapes. His phrasing is just really melodic and fluid. It's like he’s like really good man.
On the technical side, learning where the triads are up and down the neck is getting easier because of the practice I’ve been doing. I’m still mostly seeing things as patterns, and while I can track the root of each chord as it goes by, I struggle to target notes by name in real time. I’m starting to work on that, like aiming for the D# over the B chord, but once the song gets going I’m not really thinking that way. It’s still more about chord shapes, neighboring strings, and the pentatonic framework. There is more work to be done.
The second go around is mostly improvisational, and honestly why this version is the one I'm posting. I do loose track of that solo structure and I’m still working in things like arpeggiated chord tones, but overall it’s pretty unrehearsed and there something there that I like.
I could go on, but if you’re one of the handful of people who read this and listened to me play. Thank you! Please leave a comment, as always, I respond well to enthusiasm!
✌️❤️🤟
Brian
@Guitargate
Grateful Dead - Lead Guitar Roadmap
Sugaree - Improv Roadmap